The Goat Pen

dave_rickart wrote:

aTm wrote:Fails to make the playoffs 70% of the time? By my count Manning made the playoffs in 11 of the 13 seasons he played in.

i said 'failed to win a playoff game' 70% of the time.

not quite sure where you turned that into 'failed to make the playoffs'....

I noticed that too.

Peyton sucks; Brady blows; Rogers swallows.


That is all

Rickart =

ah, stated that incorrectly the second time.

again, point being that paying such an exorbitant cost for a QB and only winning a playoff game every 3-4 years isn't worth it. it would be a disappointment in the eyes of Redskin fans.

dave_rickart wrote:ah, stated that incorrectly the second time.

again, point being that paying such an exorbitant cost for a QB and only winning a playoff game every 3-4 years isn't worth it. it would be a disappointment in the eyes of Redskin fans.

Gawd, do you ever say anything that isn't 100% bullshit?!

And, yes, from the perspective of a franchise that has appeared in five Super Bowls and six NFL championship games (in the pre-Super Bowl era).... a quarterback who fails to make the playoffs over 70 percent of the time is considered a disappointment.

I saw this.

Hacksaw wrote:

dave_rickart wrote:ah, stated that incorrectly the second time.

again, point being that paying such an exorbitant cost for a QB and only winning a playoff game every 3-4 years isn't worth it. it would be a disappointment in the eyes of Redskin fans.

Gawd, do you ever say anything that isn't 100% bullshit?!

you think taking on Peyton's contract, given his age and his injury, and his track record in the postseason is 'worth it'?
(and a $28 million dolloar bonus due in March, to boot...)

when HEALTHY and in his prime, he only won a playoff game in four of his 14 seasons.

that equates to one out of 3 or 4 seasons, he manages to win a playoff game.

I just don't know why the Colts would even DREAM of trading Manning...the greatest QB of all time...

it would be a disappointment in the eyes of Redskin fans.

Utterly absurd. Peyton Manning to the Redskins would result in the most tumultuous celebration in the past two decades (since the last time the 'Skins won a SB).

Oh, pleasepleasepleasepleasepleasepleasepleasepleasepleasepleasepleasepleaseplease let it happen.

Maybe Pey-Pey can go the Giants and his brother's backup...

yes, because according to Hack, Eli > Brady

and we all know that Brady > Peyton....

and, per ESPN, Tebow > Peyton

Tebow = Christ

so peyton manning has won an NFL playoff game in 4 different years. Brady I imagine also has accomplished that

anybody else besides those two qb's win a plAyoff game in 4 different years since 2000 richart?

I love how rickart keeps saying he as if manning missed the fg's.

I cam think of at least two playoff games that would have been wins if the liquored up kicker hadn't missed.

Hell Brady is ofer last 2 years and hasn't won a game in 4 years.

anybody else besides those two qb's win a plAyoff game in 4 different years since 2000 richart?

Ben Roethlisberger, Brett Favre, Kurt Warner, Donovan McNabb

so that's 6

interstingly ncnabb won the most with 7 different seasons he won a playoff game since 2000. brady is next with 6 different seasons

THE_WIZARD_ wrote:Tebow = anti-Christ

Fixed that for you...

http://www.yahoo.com/_ylt=ArPqhcNSSiuR1 ... 08764.html

jimmy fallon nails it