The Goat Pen

and it looks like Tick is saying the Colts had the wrong Manning all along?

That was toe. Wrong again again.

so you think one Super Bowl win in an 17-year career denotes the CORRECT Manning?

sad

Jungle Rat wrote:

BigRedMan wrote:No just offering a little perspective that is all. Things I have said from day 1, it is a team sport. Sure the QB is important piece but in the end, little Tom wouldn't have a few of those rings if not for Adam kicking the winning FG.

My argument still stands that you are a grabasstic piece of amphibian shit.

So what you are saying is that Akili Smith would have multiple rings had he played for the Colts or Pats during the same time period. Got it.

Probably not. However that is like comparing a VW Bug to a Chevy Corvette. When discussing Brady and Manning, it is more like Corvette / Mustang / Charger.

And just like Peyton, you can't drive any in snow.

Who's the best running back of all time? Jim Brown? Walter Payton? Barry Sanders? O.J.? There is one NFL championship between them. There are, however, 4 league MVPs between them.

Franco Harris and Rocky Bleier, by contrast, aren't on any best-ever lists and have zero MVPs between. But each has four SB rings (as does their pedestrian QB, Awshucks Bradshaw).

Peyton Manning has all the QB records that count and FIVE league MVPs. 5 > 2. Hate that I had to draw a picture with crayons for Rickart but that's what you have to do for the learning impaired.

Only losers compare MVP awards to Super Bowl rings. As a Bengal fan I am well aware that the regular season means little if you actually make the playoffs.

Super Bowl MVPs. Brady 3, Eli 2, Peyton 1.

That should about end this.

Jungle Rat wrote:Only losers compare MVP awards to Super Bowl rings. As a Bengal fan I am well aware that the regular season means little if you actually make the playoffs.

As a bengal and a bearcat fan it's a wonder you haven't jumped off a bridge.

I have. They are just to short around here. Could be worse though. My favorite orange could be creamsicle.

hilarious that someone is STILL trying to argue Purty > TB12....

next up, Dewey defeats Truman....

It COULD be worse, rat. Any one of us could be a deadskin/Vagina fan..

Don't suck up to me.

You were a prop. Something you can handle.

I admit to a bias regarding PM, but I've seen 95% of his games since he was 18. I'd say he was the best even if he didn't hold (or is about to hold) all the QB records that are in the books. As long as he's in the conversation, I'm good with it.

And he'll be in TV ads until kingdom come, and knowing that each one raises dave's bp a few points makes me smile. Chicken parm you taste so good

"I admit to a bias regarding PM, but I've seen 95% of his games since he was 18."

I think you need to get out more...

The real question is who is better, Peyton Manning or Branndon Stewart?

Heh. Stewart may have been better as a 1st quarter freshman.

Whatever happened to Ryan Leaf?

I watched Peyton too from 18 on. Gator Bait.