The Goat Pen

is he truly comparing the careers stats of a guy who has been in the league 12 years to a guy who has been in the league nine years?

dave_rickart wrote:Hoosiers, heh.

I fucking told you.

Once again I will remind the truly thick-headed that rings are awarded to teams, not individuals.

And Manning has been in the league 2 more years than Brady. Manning's superiority over Brady is such that the 2 year difference can't explain it away. Brady would have to play for several more seasons than Manning to catch up to him.

Brady also missed a season due to injury.

don't confuse him with facts, DS.

next up, he'll announce that Peyton has better career stats than Cam Newton, Sam Bradford and Matt Ryan....

Peyton's alleged "leadership" clearly instilled heart and character in his teammates....

Why don't we get a politics and religion thread... You guys would be a hoot!

I think Peyton knew this team sucked so he had the surgery to deflect the blame on his eroding skills.

Peyton has averaged over 4,000 yards a season over his career. Brady has thrown for 4,000 yards or more only 3 times. That's just one of many examples. I can't make it any more simple than that.

And, of course, today's result showed just how much more valuable Manning is to his team than Brady. But that's not surprising. It's been obvious all along that Brady has been on the better team throughout his career. The Pats without Brady were still good. The Colts without Manning are horrible.

Game. Set. Match.

Jungle Rat wrote:I think Peyton knew this team sucked so he had the surgery to deflect the blame on his eroding skills.

He's pulling a Krzyzewski?

kansas city vs indy--oct 9 for the first draft pick of 2012

thank god we are in a shit division and

3-13 if manning doesn't play this year

Warren Moon threw for over 4,000 yards more often than Brady has.

Did that make Moon a better QB?

Well Trent Dilfer is clearly better than Moon and Marino because he has a SB ring.

The Colts look unprepared and lost on both sides of the ball. Special teams are still a disaster and with all that said, it is on coaching. Plain and simple. Caldwell has got to go. I will personally welcome the moustached messiah Jeff Fisher with some nice cigars recommended by AA, as the new head coach if they will hire him at seasons end.

Besides, we all know the Pats cheated to win their SBs and if it wasn't for Adam, Brady would be in the same discussion as Jim Kelly. You can ignore that if you want, but it's true. DAMN TRUE!!

The Colts would have sucked this year with or without Pey-Pey.

Jim Sorgi was clearly the glue....

Jungle Rat wrote:The Colts would have sucked this year with or without Pey-Pey.

Maybe but we sucked last year and still made the playoffs so can't complain to much I guess.

However, as a Bengals fan you have no right good sir to tell anyone that their team sucks.

Brown is the NFL Scumbag Steve. (if you don't know, look it up)

Refuses to trade Carson.

Gives Away Chad.

You sound bitter. Can I buy you dinner?

The Bengals are 1-0, Colts 0-1...

Then purchase SB tickets for the Bengals or STFU.

You can only get Super Bowl tickets via a lottery dumbass.